Texas School Finance: Doing the Math on the State’s Biggest Expenditure
Published January 2019
Texas school funding needs are driven primarily by enrollment, but other factors are important as well, including household income and inflation as well as various state and federal mandates.44
Today, the Texas public school system serves more than 5 million students.45
Enrollment growth is a direct consequence of Texas’ rapid population growth. The state led the nation in population growth in each year between 2010 and 2016, adding more than 3 million residents in just six years.46
Between the 1993 and 2017 school years, enrollment in Texas public schools rose by 51 percent or more than 1.8 million students.47 The student count has risen by more than 519,000 since 2010.
Household income is another factor driving school funding needs. The number of Texas students identified as “economically disadvantaged” — eligible for free or reduced-price meals — is rising (Exhibit 11), and many of them qualify for compensatory education funding and other resources.
From fiscal 2007 to 2017, the share of Texas students classified as economically disadvantaged rose from 55.5 percent to 59 percent. In this period, the number of economically disadvantaged students rose faster than the overall student population, by 24.2 percent versus 16.8 percent.
In fiscal 2017, the share of the student population classified as economically disadvantaged fell among African Americans, Hispanics, Asians and multiracial students, but increased for Anglo students.48
School Year | Economically Disadvantaged | Non-Economically Disadvantaged |
---|---|---|
1994 | 1,623,108 | 1,978,731 |
1995 | 1,699,612 | 1,970,584 |
1996 | 1,753,371 | 1,986,889 |
1997 | 1,841,185 | 1,987,790 |
1998 | 1,886,926 | 2,004,951 |
1999 | 1,914,547 | 2,030,820 |
2000 | 1,955,012 | 2,036,771 |
2001 | 2,001,697 | 2,057,922 |
2002 | 2,093,511 | 2,053,142 |
2003 | 2,201,534 | 2,038,377 |
2004 | 2,277,901 | 2,033,601 |
2005 | 2,394,001 | 1,989,870 |
2006 | 2,503,755 | 2,001,817 |
2007 | 2,540,888 | 2,036,045 |
2008 | 2,572,093 | 2,079,423 |
2009 | 2,681,474 | 2,046,730 |
2010 | 2,848,067 | 1,976,711 |
2011 | 2,909,554 | 2,002,831 |
2012 | 3,008,464 | 1,969,656 |
2013 | 3,054,741 | 2,004,198 |
2014 | 3,092,125 | 2,043,755 |
2015 | 3,068,820 | 2,146,462 |
2016 | 3,118,758 | 2,165,494 |
2017 | 3,155,117 | 2,188,717 |
Sources: Texas Education Agency and Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts
Public education funding and expenditures are affected by inflation, the steady increase in prices of goods and services over time.
From fiscal 2000 to 2018, total per-student revenue for Texas public schools rose by 70 percent, from $5,711 to $9,694. Per-student revenue from state sources rose by 34 percent, from $2,605 to $3,488, while revenue from local sources rose by 100 percent, from $3,105 to $6,206 (Exhibit 12).
After adjusting for inflation, however, total and local per-student revenue rose by 16 percent and 29 percent, respectively, but state per-student revenue actually fell by 8 percent.
Fiscal Year | Total Revenue Per Student (Current Dollars) | Total Revenue Per Student (Constant 2017 Dollars) | State Revenue Per Student (Current Dollars) | State Revenue Per Student (Constant 2017 Dollars) | Local Revenue Per Student (Current Dollars) | Local Revenue Per Student (Constant 2017 Dollars) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2000 | $5,710.70 | $8,389.10 | $2,605.50 | $3,827.40 | $3,105.30 | $4,561.70 |
2001 | $5,928.50 | $8,471.80 | $2,532.90 | $3,619.60 | $3,395.60 | $4,852.30 |
2002 | $6,245.40 | $8,781.00 | $2,455.00 | $3,451.80 | $3,790.40 | $5,329.30 |
2003 | $6,375.00 | $8,759.30 | $2,324.90 | $3,194.50 | $4,050.10 | $5,564.80 |
2004 | $6,556.60 | $8,779.30 | $2,320.90 | $3,107.70 | $4,235.70 | $5,671.60 |
2005 | $6,683.50 | $8,655.10 | $2,229.50 | $2,887.20 | $4,454.00 | $5,768.00 |
2006 | $6,826.00 | $8,559.80 | $2,084.00 | $2,613.40 | $4,742.00 | $5,946.50 |
2007 | $7,733.00 | $9,434.30 | $2,862.90 | $3,492.70 | $4,870.10 | $5,941.50 |
2008 | $7,985.60 | $9,383.10 | $3,688.50 | $4,334.00 | $4,297.10 | $5,049.10 |
2009 | $8,219.10 | $9,690.40 | $3,474.00 | $4,095.90 | $4,745.10 | $5,594.50 |
2010 | $8,398.80 | $9,742.60 | $3,712.50 | $4,306.50 | $4,686.30 | $5,436.10 |
2011 | $8,414.70 | $9,458.10 | $3,828.40 | $4,303.20 | $4,586.30 | $5,155.00 |
2012 | $8,102.90 | $8,921.30 | $3,480.50 | $3,832.10 | $4,622.30 | $5,089.20 |
2013 | $8,209.90 | $8,916.00 | $3,442.30 | $3,738.40 | $4,767.60 | $5,177.60 |
2014 | $8,670.20 | $9,259.80 | $3,659.70 | $3,908.50 | $5,010.50 | $5,351.20 |
2015 | $9,061.00 | $9,668.10 | $3,664.80 | $3,910.30 | $5,396.30 | $5,757.80 |
2016 | $9,359.20 | $9,864.60 | $3,776.90 | $3,980.90 | $5,582.30 | $5,883.70 |
2017 | $9,467.60 | $9,770.60 | $3,617.10 | $3,732.90 | $5,850.50 | $6,037.70 |
2018 | $9,694.10 | $9,694.10 | $3,488.40 | $3,488.40 | $6,205.70 | $6,205.70 |
Sources: Texas Education Agency, Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts and U.S. Inflation Calculator
Due to inflation, school districts have to spend more simply to provide the same resources to the same number of students. Exhibit 13 shows Texas school district operating expenditures per student from all sources for fiscal 2007 through 2017. In terms of current (2017) dollars, unadjusted for inflation, operating expenditures per student rose by 21 percent in that period, from $7,824 to an all-time high of $9,500. In constant 2017 dollars, however, operating expenditures per student rose by just 3 percent, from $9,239 to $9,500.
Fiscal 2017 spending was lower than in several previous fiscal years.
Fiscal Year | Current Dollars | Constant 2017 Dollars |
---|---|---|
2007 | $7,824.00 | $9,239.00 |
2008 | $8,340.00 | $9,346.00 |
2009 | $8,569.00 | $9,748.00 |
2010 | $8,799.00 | $9,896.00 |
2011 | $8,715.00 | $9,445.00 |
2012 | $8,274.00 | $8,818.00 |
2013 | $8,324.00 | $8,738.00 |
2014 | $8,690.00 | $8,970.00 |
2015 | $9,061.00 | $9,335.00 |
2016 | $9,370.00 | $9,552.00 |
2017 | $9,500.00 | $9,500.00 |
Note: Expenditures for debt service and capital outlays are excluded.
Sources: Texas Education Agency, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts
In Texas, there’s a fairly common perception that the cost of public education is, or should be, divided more or less equally between the state and local school districts — even though the state share averaged 40 percent from 2000 to 2018. Due to the funding formulas, however, there’s an inverse relationship between state and local funding — as local revenue rises, state funding generally decreases (Exhibit 14). Between fiscal 2000 and 2018, the state and local shares of total education funding averaged 40 percent and 60 percent, respectively. During this period, the state’s share fell as low as 30.5 percent in 2006, the year of the HB 1 reforms.
Fiscal Year | State Share | Local Share |
---|---|---|
2000 | 45.6% | 54.4% |
2001 | 42.7% | 57.3% |
2002 | 39.3% | 60.7% |
2003 | 36.5% | 63.5% |
2004 | 35.4% | 64.6% |
2005 | 33.4% | 66.6% |
2006 | 30.5% | 69.5% |
2007 | 37.0% | 63.0% |
2008 | 46.2% | 53.8% |
2009 | 42.3% | 57.7% |
2010 | 44.2% | 55.8% |
2011 | 45.5% | 54.5% |
2012 | 43.0% | 57.0% |
2013 | 41.9% | 58.1% |
2014 | 42.2% | 57.8% |
2015 | 40.4% | 59.6% |
2016 | 40.4% | 59.6% |
2017 | 38.2% | 61.8% |
2018 | 36.0% | 64.0% |
Sources: Texas Education Agency and Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts
The compressed tax rate introduced by HB 1 slashed M&O rates to provide property tax relief. As a result, the state and local shares came close to parity in 2008, at 46.2 percent and 53.8 percent, respectively. Since then, however, rising property values and the local-first formulas have returned the system to its prior trajectory, with the local share growing to 64.0 percent in fiscal 2018, or by an average of 1 percent annually since 2009.49
Texas’ property values have more than tripled since 1997, from $800.8 billion to about $2.8 trillion, a 248 percent increase. Even after adjustment for inflation, property values rose by 128 percent.
With those increases, recent TEA projections indicate that the state’s share of total funding will continue to fall.50 Texas’ public education funding formulas thus have ensured increasing dependence on local property taxes — and a growing burden on homeowners and businesses.
Exhibit 15 compares annual changes in Texas property values with those in sales tax revenues. The general sales tax is the most important state tax in terms of revenue, averaging 60.5 percent of state tax collections since 1993.
Year | Property Value | Change in Property Value from Previous Year | State Sales Tax Base (In Billions) | Change in State Sales Tax Base from Previous Year |
---|---|---|---|---|
1997 | $800.80 | - | $11.3 | - |
1998 | $848.00 | 0.1% | $12.5 | 0.1% |
1999 | $899.50 | 6.1% | $13.0 | 4.7% |
2000 | $988.20 | 9.9% | $14.0 | 7.6% |
2001 | $1,097.80 | 11.1% | $14.8 | 5.6% |
2002 | $1,160.00 | 5.7% | $14.6 | -1.7% |
2003 | $1,207.70 | 4.1% | $14.3 | -1.8% |
2004 | $1,282.10 | 6.2% | $15.5 | 8.0% |
2005 | $1,385.20 | 8.0% | $16.4 | 5.8% |
2006 | $1,547.50 | 11.7% | $18.3 | 12.2% |
2007 | $1,722.70 | 11.3% | $20.4 | 11.0% |
2008 | $1,904.00 | 10.5% | $21.7 | 6.5% |
2009 | $1,922.60 | 1.0% | $21.1 | -2.8% |
2010 | $1,889.10 | -1.7% | $19.7 | -6.6% |
2011 | $1,913.70 | 1.3% | $21.5 | 9.4% |
2012 | $1,998.20 | 4.4% | $24.2 | 12.5% |
2013 | $2,107.80 | 5.5% | $26.0 | 7.2% |
2014 | $2,295.90 | 8.9% | $27.5 | 6.1% |
2015 | $2,462.60 | 7.3% | $29.1 | 5.7% |
2016 | $2,598.10 | 5.5% | $28.5 | -2.2% |
2017 | $2,786.20 | 7.2% | $29.1 | 2.3% |
Note: Property value calculations are for tax years 1997 to 2017; sales tax calculations are for fiscal 1997 to 2017.
Sources: Texas Education Agency and Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts
Collections from both sales and property taxes can vary dramatically from year to year, but sales tax revenue is much more vulnerable to economic downturns. The exhibit shows sales tax revenue over time as the estimated amount of sales tax collections that would have been received if the Tax Code had not changed during the study period (i.e., since 1996). This removes the effects of legislative changes to capture only volatility induced by the economy. Property values saw only one annual decrease from 1997 to 2017, while sales tax revenue declined five times.
State severance taxes levied on oil and gas production are even more volatile than sales taxes (Exhibit 16), experiencing double-digit changes in every year since 1997.
Fiscal Year | Base | Change |
---|---|---|
1996 | $824,077 | |
1997 | $1,141,372 | 38.50% |
1998 | $885,403 | -22.43% |
1999 | $728,945 | -17.67% |
2000 | $1,139,902 | 56.38% |
2001 | $2,089,736 | 83.33% |
2002 | $994,841 | -52.39% |
2003 | $1,542,341 | 55.03% |
2004 | $1,953,224 | 26.64% |
2005 | $2,438,425 | 24.84% |
2006 | $3,346,552 | 37.24% |
2007 | $2,864,429 | -14.41% |
2008 | $4,307,649 | 50.38% |
2009 | $2,419,657 | -43.83% |
2010 | $1,881,658 | -22.23% |
2011 | $2,737,815 | 45.50% |
2012 | $3,819,099 | 39.49% |
2013 | $4,670,893 | 22.30% |
2014 | $5,913,162 | 26.60% |
2015 | $4,259,794 | -27.96% |
2016 | $2,371,636 | -44.33% |
2017 | $3,174,630 | 33.86% |
Source: Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts
Between 1997 and 2017, the annual change in property values ranged from -1.7 percent to +11.7 percent, while that of sales taxes varied more broadly, from -6.6 percent to +12.5 percent. Annual changes in severance tax collections ranged from -52.4 percent to +83.3 percent. The compound annual growth rates of property values, sales tax revenues and severance tax revenues in this period were 6.4 percent, 4.8 percent and 6.6 percent, respectively (Exhibit 17).
Growth Rate | Property Values | State Sales Tax Revenue | State Severance Tax Revenue |
---|---|---|---|
Maximum Growth Rate | 11.7% | 12.5% | 83.3% |
Minimum Growth Rate | -1.7% | -6.6% | -52.4% |
Compound Annual Growth Rate | 6.4% | 4.8% | 6.6% |
Note: Tax revenues adjusted to reflect those that would have been collected if the state’s sales tax laws had not changed in the period studied. Property value calculations are for tax years 1997-2017; sales tax and severance tax calculations are for fiscal 1997-2017.
Source: Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts